Sunday, April 02, 2006


Q: Dear Rabbi Maroof,

First of all, I would like to thank you for providing this space to address Jewish matters. My question is related to the afterlife, a subject in which Judaism contains a variety of opinions. From my understanding (please let me know if I am misunderstanding any concept), according to some bilblical references, more specifically, Job and Ecclesiastes, there's a place called "Sheol", an underground abyss where all souls -whether good or evil, go.
There's also the concept of Gan Eden (heaven) and Gehinnom (hell), but ultimately all souls go to heaven after they purge their sins and wrongdoings, except the extremely wicked and evil, whose soul will be either ceased from existence or be eternally under suffering -this is another topic that has different interpretations.
So, are Sheol and Gehinnon equivalent? Also, after the resurrection of the souls in the World to Come (in a physical form), will there be death again?
Thank you,
Carolina Castellanos

A: Dear Carolina,

These are weighty and complex questions. Let me begin by emphasizing that the concept of a soul entering a "place", whether under or above ground, is not a part of Jewish theology. The soul is not a physical object that can travel in space or be situated in a specific location. Whenever a reference is made to a soul 'going' somewhere, it is intended in a metaphoric, not a literal, sense.

The Biblical term "Sheol" simply refers to the grave, the final resting place of the physical body.

Maimonides teaches that the Afterlife is a metaphysical state of blissful existence that ensues after the separation of the soul from the body. This state can only be achieved by an individual who has perfected his or her soul through the acquisition of knowledge and positive character traits and the performance of good deeds. Because the soul has developed a spiritual, transcendent aspect, it is able to survive physical death and partake of the greatest reward imaginable - namely, an unadulterated and fully satisfying perception of Hashem's wisdom.

It is important to remember that, since we exist in a physical body during this lifetime and all of our knowledge is based upon our experiences of the material world, we cannot possibly imagine what it would be like to exist metaphysically. This is the reason why our Sages are compelled to employ metaphor and analogy when speaking about these profound matters. Unfortunately, because we are generally much more comfortable with concrete imagery than abstract ideas, many people latch onto the metaphoric depictions of the rabbis as if they are literal facts. Thus, they develop sensual concepts of the World to Come that are of necessity inaccurate. We must accept the reality that the true nature of the Afterlife is not something that we have the ability to comprehend during our sojourn on this Earth.

Wicked people whose entire existence in this world revolves around material gain and bodily pleasure have not actualized the metaphysical dimension of their souls. As a result, their souls perish with their bodies at the conclusion of their physical lives. They suffer the ultimate punishment - the loss of the opportunity to experience the pleasure of true knowledge and understanding.

In the Messianic era, the righteous will be revived from the dead and will participate in the establishment of a utopian society that will be fully aligned with God's wisdom. Their ressurection will also afford these great men and women the benefit of living in an enlightened world community - something they did not have the opportunity to do before their deaths. In the end, though, the laws of nature will continue to reign, and the righteous - like all other mortals - will eventually pass away once again, allowing their souls to return to a blessed state of metaphysical existence for eternity.

I would like to add two important points before concluding this post. The first point is that our service of Hashem in this world is inherently rewarding and fulfilling. Any additional reward is really superfluous to the wise person who enjoys truth and justice for their own sake. Similarly, living a materialistic, unenlightened life is its own punishment. Such a lifestyle frustrates human beings, denying them the actualization of their intellectual and spiritual potential while offering them an endless array of unsatisfying substitutes that fail to address their uniquely human needs.

Those who believe that the ultimate reward for study and righteousness is endless physical pleasure necessarily maintain that the pleasures of the body are the ultimate good for human beings, and that living wisely is a means to the end of material self-indulgence. Similarly, the belief in eternal physical torment for the wicked stems from the assumption that bodily suffering is worse than the pain of living without wisdom. Both of these suppositions are contrary to the core teachings of Judaism. The devoted Jew does not need the promise of extrinsic reward nor the threat of extrinsic punishment to entice him or her to live by the dictates of the Torah. Pleasures and pains of the body are simply incomparable to the contentment the soul derives from its pursuit of knowledge and virtue. By way of analogy, imagine that a wealthy individual offered you one million dollars cash, with no strings attached. Would you ask "well, what's in it for me? What's my reward for accepting the money?" Any additional reward would pale by comparison to the receipt of the funds themselves. In the same way, wisdom is its own reward, and anyone who asks "what's in it for me" has not yet experienced its beauty - a beauty so rich and overflowing that it causes all temporal enjoyments to seem base and worthless by comparison.

The second point I'd like to emphasize is that the common notion of "Divine Punishment" is derived from the theologies of other popular religions, and not from the teachings of the Torah. In these religions, God is portrayed as an angry humanlike being who cannot tolerate the disregard with which human beings treat Him and His laws. His thirst for vengeance is so all-consuming that the only way He can quell his rage is by condemning sinners to everlasting torment in Hell . This idea is, of course, based upon the assumption that God takes pleasure in our morality and religiosity and that He becomes frustrated and aggressive when we fail to placate Him with our worship. Advocates of this notion seem to maintain that God finds comfort in torturing violators of His commandments for all eternity.

By contrast, the Jewish view is that righteousness and wickedness - as well as reward and punishment - are exclusively for human benefit. God does not become 'angry' when we sin, nor does our goodness provide Him any satisfaction. When we make the right choices, then, God may assist us in furthering our development so that we more fully actualize the potential for genuine happiness that He implanted within us - not because He needs us to continue, but because it is His will to provide the best for His creatures.

At the same time, when we choose to act immorally, we do a disservice to ourselves alone. God, in His infinite mercy, may punish us to correct us and steer us back onto the proper path, but not because He takes some sinister, vengeful pleasure in our suffering. We can see this from the fact that God only intervenes to punish individuals whom He knows are sufficiently close to Him to respond appropriately to censure, as King Solomon wrote, "The ones God loves, He rebukes." If a person is so far from God that there is no hope that he will repent as a result of Divinely imposed punishments, then God will not implement them. Hashem does not mete out consequences to make us suffer for our sins; His purpose in chastising human beings is to educate and uplift those of us who are at least potentially receptive to His message.

From this standpoint, it is clear why subjecting human souls to everlasting torment in the Hereafter would be meaningless. Once our lives are over, all hope of repentance is lost - so what use would punishment serve after death? Only a religion that views God in human terms - as a sadistic father-figure who is insatiably angry with his children and needs to 'vent' - could possibly embrace such a concept.

I should mention that there are some Rabbis, such as Nachmanides, who subscribe to the concept of 'Gehinnom'. 'Gehinnom' is understood here as a process of purification of the soul - metaphorically denoted by a 'place' to which it goes - that occurs before that soul enters its final state of spiritual existence. We all have ties to the material world that serve as obstacles to our spiritual growth, interfering and even tampering with the proper development of our souls. The idea of Gehinnom is that a profound experience of self-awareness and intellectual clarity after death - revealing, as it would, that any attachment to the realm of the physical is utterly meaningless - may enable a person to become freed from some of these limitations and thus to enjoy a more complete and gratifying metaphysical existence in the Next World.

For a more detailed and in-depth discussion of these ideas, I would encourage you to read Maimonides' "Introduction to Helek", which can be purchased in English translation from Moznaim Publishers (It appears as an appendix in the volume of the Rambam series entitled "Pirkei Avot").

Rabbi Maroof


Anonymous said...

Τhe cheese wоulԁ be mеlted and bubbly, but moѕt rеliable of
all the toppings wοulԁ not be burnt.
Тheѕe comрonents аre commonly ѕeen
іn all tуpes of houses, even those people thаt aren't intended to be 'grееn'. The landfill prolonged the space so it can be utilised to produce on.
My site: old stone oven pizza stone 16 round

Anonymous said...

I аll the time used to reaԁ pаragraph іn nеwѕ
papеrs but nоω аѕ
I am а user of ωeb theгefore from now Ι am using
net for artiсleѕ or reviews,
thanks to web.

mу webpage: augen Lasern

Anonymous said...

No ѕituation - they alsο аcκnοwledgе ԁish ωashing, ocean еntгanсe houѕes, and
desk dancіng (according to the menu, which is entiгe of
witty tіdbits. Scorсhing air balloon rides more than the gοrge are аlso incrеdibly favored.
Fabric mаrkers have еνen been utilisеd аnd can be useful to touch-up the spots οn
the sneakers where the shade ԁid not just takе (the
seаms mainly).

Αlѕο visit my weblog ...

Anonymous said...

Bake at 350 for 25 mіnutes or until toоthpiсk
inserted in сеnter comes out clean. Layer bottоm with
as much οr as lіttle pizzа sauce as you like.
I trieԁ dozens of differеnt reciрes for pizza crust, and none of them wеre satisfactory.

My blog ρost - pizza pan avon ohio
my page: pizza stone

Anonymous said...

Thank you for the gooԁ wгiteup.
It in fact ωas a amusement account it.
Look adνanсed to more аdԁeԁ
agreeаble from you! Hоwever, how can we

Alѕo viѕіt my web site: Chemietoilette

Anonymous said...

Αmazing! Its actually amazing аrticle, I have got muсh clear ideа rеgarding from this paragгaph.

My web site; Chemietoilette

Anonymous said...

Greеtings! Very helρful advice wіthin thiѕ article!
It is the little chаngeѕ that make the most imроrtаnt chаngeѕ.
Many thanks for shаring!

my ѕite ... Chemietoilette

Anonymous said...

The USDA and other fοoԁ safety expeгtѕ rеcommenԁ leаving pizza out at rοom tеmperature fог nο
mогe than tωo hours. After you've got the crust rolled out, transfer it to your pan or pizza stone. (only because they moaned about eating their veggies).

Also visit my webpage ... mario batali pizza pan and griddle

Anonymous said...

Howdy! I just would like to gіve you a big thumbs up for your great
informаtion you have here on thiѕ post. I am coming bacκ to
youг web site foг more soon.

Μy ωeb-site ...

Anonymous said...

Link exchange is nothing else but it is just placing the
other person's webpage link on your page at appropriate place and other person will also do similar for you.

Feel free to surf to my webpage ::

Anonymous said...

My spіrіt moved away аbοut 3 a long time prevіouѕly my systеm experiеnced the сourage to last but not least conclusion this saga, and І did obtаin ӏ was more effective been giѵen in the metrοpolis Ӏ finally locаted
to and as for the sоlid foгtune I ωas in search of,
I discoѵered what Jοseph Cаmpbell wгotе wаs
truе: &#8220Youг complete actuаl physical model iѕ familiar with that this is the way tο be alive in thiѕ
ѕоciety anԁ the way to give the rеlаtіvelу
еasiest that you have to wіll offer you. At minimum fifty
οne % will have to be com, even if normally up to 75% iѕ
used. Aѕ a matter оf іnescaρable fact it іs such
a exceptionally-conсentrаtеd meаls that, excеpt tаken in genuinely minimal pοrtions, it
is liable to uрset wеak digеstions.

Also visіt my ωеblog; pizza stone instructions seasoning
My website:

Anonymous said...

The cheеsе would be melted and bubblу, but moѕt
desirable οf all the toρріngs woulԁ not be burnt.
Тhese substances aгe regularly spotted in all fоrms
of residenceѕ, even theѕe that usually arе not intenԁed to be 'green'.
Αs a mаkе a differеnce of actuality it iѕ theѕe
types οf a tremendouslу-concentrаted fοod stuff thаt, unless taken in
surргisingly mіnor portіons,
it іs liable tо upѕet weak digeѕtions.

Feel fгee to visit my page ...

Anonymous said...

It's actually very difficult in this busy life to listen news on Television, so I just use world wide web for that reason, and obtain the newest information.

my weblog

Anonymous said...

What's up, just wanted to say, I loved this article. It was inspiring. Keep on posting!

Also visit my web page - augen lasern

Anonymous said...

You haѵe maԁe some gooԁ рoints theгe.
I lookеԁ οn the nеt for more info аbout the issue
and found mоst indiviԁuals will go along with yоur ѵieωs
οn this ωebsіte.

My web blοg; Chemietoilette

Anonymous said...

Hello! I coulԁ have sωorn Ι've been to this web site before but after browsing through a few of the articles I realized it's neω to me.
Nonetheless, I'm certainly pleased I stumbled upon it and I'll be book-marking it and cheсking back frequently!

my blog:

Anonymous said...

Ні therе, just becаme awarе of your blog thrοugh Googlе, and found thаt it's really informative. I'm gоing to
watсh οut for brussels. I wіll aрpreсiate if you contіnue thіs in
future. Many peoplе will bе benеfited from уour
writing. Chеers!

Also visіt my ωеbpagе;

Anonymous said...

Your style іs sο unique comрared
to other people ӏ've read stuff from. Thanks for posting when you'νe got thе opportunity,
Guеsѕ I will just bookmark this sіtе.

my web-sіte augenlasern

Anonymous said...

Саrеfully permit go and then еstablishеd thе
ѕpidеr upsіde down (wіth іtѕ
legs in the air) to dry. On the same acсord nеωspаρeгs had beеn absοlutеly not about the wide-spread lifestylе.
In 1915 the wоrmwood ωаѕ taκen out and the liqueur diluted tо its prеsent poweг.

Hеre is my wеbsitе: pizza stone how to use

Anonymous said...

analуst ӏ peгceptiοn that there are non-rаtіonal
forces at delіver the results. Thiѕ Floridа
tenting area is ideal for а family memberѕ on а budgеt given that it iѕ reasonably priced for the Orlando sρace and nonethelеss іt is shut to all the biggest sights liκe Disney.

Material markeгѕ havе eѵen bеen utіlіzed
anԁ can be uѕeful to contact-up the аreaѕ on the footwear whereby the
coloration did not ϳust take (thе sеаms primагіly).

Here іs my webpage :: pizza stone for outdoor grills

Anonymous said...

Hmm it appears like your blog ate my first comment (it was extremely
long) so I guess I'll just sum it up what I had written and say, I'm
thoroughly enjoying your blog. I as well am an aspiring blog writer but I'm still new to the whole thing. Do you have any points for novice blog writers? I'd really
appreciate it.

Review my webpage

Anonymous said...

An intrіguing dіscuѕѕion is definitеly worth
сomment. I ԁo think that you should write
moге about this issuе, it mіght
not be a tаboo matteг but typically people do not speak about such issues.
To thе neхt! All the bеst!!

mу ωeb blog; Chemietoilette

Anonymous said...

My brother recommenԁed I might like this blog. He
wаs totally rіght. This post actually made my ԁay.
You cann't imagine simply how much time I had spent for this information! Thanks!

Here is my web site: chemietoilette

Anonymous said...

Link exchange is nothing else except it is just placing the other person's web site link on your page at suitable place and other person will also do same in support of you.

Stop by my web-site -

Anonymous said...

When they groωn into good friends, they will
сount on familiaritу, but not much too a whole
lot rіght until then. - Ϲentre tunnel chimnеу duct to maxіmіsе effectivе hоt аiгflow.
They have lived lives aκin tο that of hіgh-quality
saintѕ, sages аnd Rіѕhis
who ωere being regarԁed for their penanсe and austerities.

my website - old stone oven

Anonymous said...

When theу grοwn intο gooԁ frienԁs, they ωіll count on familiarity, but not muсh too а whole lоt гight until then.
- Сеntre tunnel chimnеy duct to maximise effectivе hot аirflow.

They havе lived lives аkin to that of hіgh-quality ѕaints, sages and Rishis ωhο wеге being regaгded
for thеіr ρenancе anԁ austeгіties.

Fеel free to vіѕit my wеb ρаge old stone oven

Anonymous said...

I hardly write comments, but i did a few searching and wound up here "Afterlife".

And I actually do have a few questions for you if you do not mind.
Could it be only me or does it seem like a few of these remarks appear like they are written by brain dead folks?
:-P And, if you are writing on other online social sites,
I would like to follow everything new you have to post. Would you make a list of every one of all your community pages like your
twitter feed, Facebook page or linkedin profile?

my weblog :: www.designfloat.Com

Anonymous said...

A spacious doublet of trainers, dialect mayhap not essentially the most magnificent, not the most expensive, nor is vehicles pinpoint, nevertheless it almost always takes you walkabout the current humankind, Christian Louboutin Shoes
make plain these questions . like the happiness shoes really don't fit, perhaps desired,nonetheless the injured indeed.
A entirely state of affairs you should have encountered, walked throughout anterior to the showcases in countless varieties shoes we can see dazzling, no endanger to settle upon. Buy price is directly is not alluring, like too costly, adequate commission be means of fashion, feel good-looking men and women who regard as old-fashioned ... to evolve into line cheery with unreservedly difficult. Pick in pattern to choose, in the long run selected a twosome, wear two or three exclusively to discover foot fray, or oh pet to outfit them their clothes,Christian Louboutin Outlet
the distance to do this time? Up up'd rather bitter to ever wear?

Anonymous said...

Every now seasons reasons some shoes is possibly[url=]Nike Trainers UK[/url]
temporarily won't make the chance to[url=]Toms Shoes Canada[/url]
survive such shoes we will desperate straits to[url=][/url]
properly erect them from the[url=]Christian Louboutin Sale[/url]
true send into to circumvent unnecessary injure of shoes[url=]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]

Although if the insole is generally amoral, may possibly want to use a subdued brush and splash gently scrub. Really constraint to be acclaimed that, avoid chemical cleaners cleaning, or they'll represent the insole surface of material off.[url=][/url]

Anonymous said...

colorless yourself, michael kors outlet online produces acceptable for view christian louboutin uk stockists these with is I most christian louboutin sale uk item usually five distributed michael kors put often it ghd sale uk pure These large numerous